 |
| Justice Shekhar Yadav |
Allahabad UP (Tamsil Shahezad) - Sitting Allahabad High Court Judge Justice Shekhar Kumar Yadav has once again sparked nationwide debate following his recent remarks at a Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP) event. Known for his controversial statements, Justice Yadav’s comments have consistently drawn attention for their ideological undertones, both in his judicial orders and public addresses.
Controversial Address at VHP Event
Delivering a lecture titled Uniform Civil Code: A Constitutional Necessity on Sunday, Justice Yadav touched upon polarizing themes, asserting that India should function according to the wishes of its majority. He made several pointed statements, including derogatory remarks against the Muslim community, claiming their practices foster intolerance. Justice Yadav also urged VHP members to work towards making India a “Vishwa Guru” (world leader), emphasizing Hindu supremacy.
Highlighting historical grievances, he stated that "our ancestors sacrificed for the Ram temple at Ayodhya," asserting that such efforts must continue to preserve India’s cultural fabric. His comments equating India’s potential decline with that of Taliban-ruled regions further added to the uproar.
Past Judicial Observations
Justice Yadav is no stranger to controversy. His orders have often reflected ideological leanings:
Cow as National Animal: In 2021, Justice Yadav suggested declaring the cow India’s national animal, citing unscientific claims that cows exhale oxygen and that cow by-products can cure diseases.
Religious Conversions: In cases involving alleged forced conversions, he repeatedly criticized religious fanaticism and warned against weakening India’s cultural integrity.
Free Speech Limitations: He argued that freedom of expression should not extend to hurting religious sentiments, as seen in his bail order for a man accused of posting offensive content about Hindu deities.
Praise for Prime Minister Modi
Justice Yadav has also openly praised Prime Minister Narendra Modi. During the COVID-19 pandemic, he lauded the government’s vaccination drive and even recommended postponing elections to mitigate the spread of the Omicron variant.
Judicial and Academic Career
Appointed as an Additional Judge of the Allahabad High Court in December 2019 and made permanent in 2021, Justice Yadav’s legal career spans decades. With a focus on constitutional law, he has held positions as government advocate and senior counsel for various institutions, including the Union of India.
Response and Criticism
Justice Yadav’s remarks have elicited sharp criticism. Civil society groups and legal professionals have accused him of undermining judicial neutrality. The Campaign for Judicial Accountability and Reforms (CJAR) recently lodged a complaint with the Chief Justice of India, condemning his language as "unpardonable slurs" against minorities.
Impact on Judiciary and Society
As Justice Yadav continues to blend personal ideology with judicial duty, questions about judicial impartiality grow louder. His statements have ignited debates over the role of personal beliefs in public office and the judiciary’s responsibility to uphold constitutional values.
For comprehensive analysis of Justice Yadav’s speeches and rulings, visit NEWS LINES.
Tags
Law